Comparing 2024 and 1932

In 1976, I had the opportunity to visit the preserved concentration camp in Dachau with my parents. It was a moving experience, akin, I would guess, to a visit to the Holocaust Museum, which I’ve never visited.

More recently, only a week after October 7, I visited the Anne Frank House and did a tour of the Ghetto in Venice. In Europe, while the Jewish population is smaller than in America, the Holocaust seems to be remembered in a different, perhaps more pervasive way.

We’ve read many books and seen many films about this period in history, including last year’s ‘The Zone of Interest’ — the new Netflix series about the Nuremberg trials. The Netflix series is based on William Shirer’s book, ‘The Rise and Fall of the Third Reich,’ a book that was prominently placed on a bookshelf in the home I grew up in.

This is just to say, I may have a little more empathy now for what my parents must have experienced growing up, in this country, in the 1930s and 1940s. Netanyahu’s brutality in Gaza in response to Hamas attacks, and his stubborn continuation of the attacks, has revitalized anti-semitism worldwide. The circumstances were different, but I’m guessing my parents experienced a form of the same thing. I remember my father telling me about the anti-semitic text in classified ads at the time, and I see similar sentiments now in social media.

They faced the threat of totalitarianism spreading throughout Europe, Asia, and beyond. The fears I now have about losing democracy in the United States, after my grandparents escaped Russia and Austria to flee oppression, may be similar to the fears they had when fascism was gaining ground in Europe and here in the U.S.

The similarities are alarming. It may turn out differently now that Ukraine is receiving support from the United States and the EU.

Russia exemplifies what autocracy looks like. The country is isolated from much of the world, including the West. After a brief emergence following the Cold War and before Putin, the Russian people have been completely robbed of free speech. I imagine there is great literature being written in Russia now that will never be published.

World War II was a heavy price for that generation to pay. Hopefully, with NATO’s expansion and the support Ukraine is now receiving from the United States and Europe, Russia will find a way to stop attacking Ukraine and respect Europe’s borders.

Here’s a little comparison of 1932 and 2024:

19322024
Hitler (after prison)Trump (before prison)
Roosevelt and Hilter electedBiden or Trump elected
Poland (1939)Ukraine
GoebbelsFox News
Hatred of JewsHatred of migrant workers
Political violencePolitical violence
Mein KampfProject 2025

Unfortunately, I think the Republican Party is bigger than the Nazi party was at that time, although the hardcore Trump supporters might be about the same size.

Who would have thought it could happen here? I didn’t. I’m hoping for a blue wave, enough to reverse the trajectory of human rights being taken away. It would be nice to see fascism squashed in elections, prompting a new, smarter Republican Party. As a lifelong, progressive Democrat, I’ve always enjoyed a good discussions with Republicans about various issues. There’s always something to learn from a different perspective. But these days, they present facts, (ie. ‘the election was stolen’) that are not only in dispute but obviously fabricated. It’s hard for me to engage with that.

While the 1930s are well known from film, the people who lived through those times are gone. While I’m relieved to see Project 2025 gaining major media attention now, I still see the polls and wonder if Americans understand what could happen. The people in Germany didn’t mind losing their rights at first because they really loved Hitler, but they ended up losing much more than they had bargained for.

Project 2025, combined with the Supreme Court’s recent decision on presidential immunity, along with threats to judges, witnesses, and juries, all suggest a scenario similar to Hitler’s takeover.

I hope it won’t happen, but if it does, I don’t think Americans will like it. Americans love the First Amendment, and Project 2025 would enable Trump to use the Justice Department to target journalists he doesn’t like, effectively ending the free press in the United States. He is already somehow preventing ‘The Apprentice,’ a new movie that received an eight-minute standing ovation at Cannes Film Festival, from finding distribution in the U.S., despite its success internationally.

Many Americans complain about censorship on social media. That’s not censorship. That’s social media. Real censorship is when it’s an official act by the president.

I don’t think Americans will like that at all. Trump could also arrest political opponents under the guise of an ‘official act’ and claim immunity. He’s said this is the basis of his campaign, “retribution.” I don’t think Americans will like that either.

Trump could take over with a minority, just as Hitler did. January 6 was similar to Hitler’s Putsch, his first attempt at a coup, after which he went to prison and wrote Mein Kampf. Their sense of entitlement to power, for the sake of the nation, regardless of the vote, is strikingly similar. They prefer ordination over democratic selection. This desire to create autocracy in the United States has always been here, but who would have thought that could become this popular? But it has.

Hopefully, it will be put down and this country will achieve the kind of democracy we can all be proud of. I listened to Biden’s speech today. He talk about future possibilities. He didn’t mention a blue wave, but he knows he would need both houses to make it happen. He talked about many things, including:

  • Restoration of Women’s Rights
  • Voting Rights
  • Assault Weapons Ban
  • Child Tax Credit
  • Secure Medicare and Social Security
  • Tax Fairness
  • American Manufacturing

With a blue wave, these things may also be possible, bringing democracy closer to realization in America:

  • Expanded Supreme Court
  • Statehood for D.C.
  • Congressional action to rein in Citizens United
  • Immigration reform
  • Universal background checks

While reclaiming the rights the current Supreme Court has taken away will take years, a Congress with a clear majority and a president of the same party could fix much of it. If the dems had both houses, with a few seats to spare, there would be huge pressure to eliminate the filibuster. It’s nice to think about that. I’d like to see the Democrats win big and end Trumpism, achieving substantial progress. Eventually, the Republican Party could be reborn, though I doubt that’s a likely outcome.

It’s better to be governed by democratic mechanisms than by a person. We’ve lost some of those mechanisms here in North Carolina, which, thanks to gerrymandering, is one of the least democratic states in the country. But why would we give ultimate power to a person? History shows that does not end well.

My grandmother participated in a political protest in Latvia in 1905. She was around 12 or 15. When the Czar started rounding people up, her father urged her to leave the country, which she did.

Many years later, while watching the trampling scene in Doctor Zhivago, she muttered in the cinema, tears in her eyes, “It was just like that.”

I hope it’s not like that here. Comparing Trump to Hitler has always been a sensitive area. The H-word can get you banned on TikTok now. Using the words Hitler or Nazi in comparison to Trump usually offends people, but I still do it sometimes. I don’t call people names, but Trump has always reminded me of Hitler, and I’ve made that comparison, knowing those are hot words.

What gives me hope is that those words seem to be circulating more widely now that Project 2025 has emerged, and more people are beginning to take this threat seriously.

Fortunately, history does not repeat itself exactly. In 1932, the United States and Germany made different choices. We elected Roosevelt. Hitler got enough votes to eventually overtake the government. There are similarities. Vote blue.